From The Adventures of Ed & Serenity

Choosing the right cruise line can feel overwhelming—especially when two of the industry’s biggest names both promise fun, food, and unforgettable voyages. To make it easier, here’s a clear, comprehensive, blog-ready comparison of Royal Caribbean and Carnival Cruise Line, covering ships, dining, entertainment, activities, private destinations, ports, and the overall vibe of each brand.

Whether you’re a first-time cruiser or planning your next adventure, this guide lays it all out so you can match the cruise line to your travel style.


—

Overall Vibe

Royal Caribbean

Built for adventure with a strong “wow factor.” Bigger ships, futuristic neighborhoods, impressive engineering, and innovative thrills like surf simulators, skydiving tunnels, robot bartenders, and massive entertainment productions. Great for families, couples, and anyone who likes nonstop activities.

Carnival

Known as “America’s Fun Ship.” High-energy, social, and value-packed with a focus on laid-back fun, comedy, nightlife, and great included dining. Ideal for fun-loving adults, families, and travelers looking for a lively atmosphere without spending a fortune.


—

Ships & Classes

Royal Caribbean Ship Classes

Class Notable Ships Length Range Guest Capacity

Icon Class Icon, Star, Utopia (coming) ~1,198 ft 5,610–7,600
Oasis Class Oasis, Allure, Harmony, Symphony, Wonder ~1,181 ft 5,400–6,988
Quantum Class Quantum, Anthem, Ovation, Spectrum, Odyssey ~1,138 ft 4,100–4,900
Freedom Class Freedom, Independence, Liberty ~1,111 ft 3,600–4,000
Voyager Class Voyager, Explorer, Adventure, Navigator, Mariner ~1,020 ft 3,100–3,800
Radiance Class Radiance, Brilliance, Serenade, Jewel ~962 ft 2,100–2,500
Vision Class Vision, Enchantment, Rhapsody, Grandeur ~915–990 ft 1,900–2,400


Carnival Ship Classes

Class Notable Ships Length Range Guest Capacity

Excel Class Mardi Gras, Celebration, Jubilee ~1,130 ft 5,200–6,600
Vista Class Vista, Horizon, Panorama ~1,055 ft 3,954–4,200
Dream Class Dream, Magic, Breeze ~1,004 ft 3,600–4,000
Conquest Class Conquest, Glory, Liberty, Freedom, Valor ~953 ft 2,974–3,800
Spirit Class Spirit, Pride, Legend, Miracle ~960 ft 2,100–2,200
Sunshine Class Sunshine 893 ft ~3,000
Fantasy Class (retired) — — —



—

Included Dining

Royal Caribbean

Included:

Main dining room (multi-level)

Windjammer Marketplace buffet

Café Promenade

Park Café (on select ships)

Sorrento’s Pizza

El Loco Fresh (Tex-Mex, on select ships)

Solarium Bistro (some ships)

Coastal Kitchen (suite guests)


Specialty:
Chops Grille, Jamie’s Italian, Giovanni’s Kitchen, Wonderland, 150 Central Park, Izumi Sushi & Teppanyaki, Hooked Seafood, Mason Jar (on Wonder), Playmakers Sports Bar, Chef’s Table, and more depending on ship.

Carnival

Included:

Main dining room

Lido Marketplace buffet

Guy’s Burger Joint

Guy’s Pig & Anchor BBQ

BlueIguana Cantina

Pizzeria del Capitano

Carnival Deli

Swirls soft-serve

Shaq’s Big Chicken (select ships)


Specialty:
Fahrenheit 555 Steakhouse, Bonsai Sushi, Bonsai Teppanyaki, Cucina del Capitano, Rudi’s Seagrill, Emeril’s Bistro (Excel class), JavaBlue Café, Seafood Shack, and more.


—

Entertainment & Nightlife

Royal Caribbean

Royal is known for mega-productions:

Broadway-style shows (e.g., Mamma Mia, Hairspray)

Ice-skating shows

AquaTheater diving performances

Laser tag

Live bands and pub musicians

Comedy clubs

Parades and themed parties

Original productions on Icon and Oasis classes


Carnival

Carnival leans into fun, humor, and nighttime energy:

Punchliner Comedy Club (a highlight)

Playlist Productions musical shows

Deck parties & themed events

Casino action

Piano bars and live musicians

Karaoke

Adult-only late-night entertainment



—

Activities & Thrills

Royal Caribbean

Royal ships are loaded with big-attraction thrills:

Surf simulators (FlowRider)

Zip lines

Roller skating

Bumper cars

RipCord skydiving simulator

Escape rooms

Waterparks and slides

Mini-golf, sports courts

Climbing walls

Ice rinks

Aquadomes (Icon Class)

—

Carnival

Carnival focuses on active fun with a lighter feel:

Bolt Roller Coaster (Excel class)

WaterWorks slides

Ropes courses

Bolt & SkyRide

Mini golf

SportsSquare

Poolside contests & games

Serenity adults-only retreat



—

Private Destinations

Royal Caribbean

Perfect Day at CocoCay (Bahamas) — Thrill Waterpark, Oasis Lagoon, Coco Beach Club, Up, Up & Away balloon ride.

Labadee (Haiti) — Dragon’s Breath zip line, coasters, beaches (currently closed in 2024–2025 operational cycles depending on conditions).


Carnival

Half Moon Cay (shared with Holland America) — Pristine beach day, horseback riding, cabanas.

Amber Cove (Dominican Republic) — Pool complex, adventure excursions.

Celebration Key (Bahamas) — Opening 2025, designed for Carnival exclusives with beaches, pool zones, dining, and activities.



—

Home Ports & Itineraries

Royal Caribbean

Major U.S. homeports:

Miami

Fort Lauderdale

Port Canaveral

Tampa

Galveston

Los Angeles (seasonal)

Seattle (Alaska)

New York/New Jersey


Destinations:
Caribbean, Bahamas, Bermuda, Alaska, Mexico, Europe, Mediterranean, Greek Isles, Middle East, Asia, South Pacific.

Carnival

Major U.S. homeports:

Miami

Port Canaveral

Tampa

Galveston

New Orleans

Mobile

Charleston

Long Beach

Baltimore


Destinations:
Caribbean, Bahamas, Mexico, Alaska, Bermuda, occasional Europe and transatlantic sailings.


—

Who Each Cruise Line Is Best For

Royal Caribbean

Perfect for travelers who want wow-factor, big thrills, futuristic ships, over-the-top entertainment, and dynamic adventures.

Carnival

Best for cruisers who enjoy high-energy fun, nightlife, great food that’s mostly included, and excellent value without sacrificing experience.


—

Final Thoughts

Both Royal Caribbean and Carnival deliver memorable vacations—it ultimately comes down to what kind of fun you want. One brings jaw-dropping attractions and modern innovation; the other brings laughter, flavor, and a non-stop party atmosphere. No matter which you choose, remember: your cruise is what you make it. Try new things, eat everything, relax, explore, and most of all—have fun.